Sunday, June 10, 2012

Entry 12: Construction Planning (A)

10 June 2012
By Kai Xiang (Destiny CKX)

After contacting Frankie, a construction expert who was helping us construct the prototype, I went down personally to his factory to discuss about the feasibility of the latest prototype.

Frankie, being an engineering expert, pointed out some of the issues of the prototype. They are as follows:

1. The legs of the display base (table) cannot be adjustable. Doing so would weaken the legs, which support the display base, thus causing it to break easily and topple over. However, he mentioned that he would see if it is possible to construct adjustable legs.

2. The display base cannot use the initial "slide" design as a sliding mechanism is
  a. too expensive
  b. tedious and difficult to construct in the time period
  c. there are better alternatives to this

Thus, the current best way would be to use an ordinary table, drill it into half, insert a board in the middle, drill holes into the sides of the table (and into the board), utilising the "Lock and Key" technique to expand the length of the table. However, this could potentially affect the stability of the table. Still, it was worth a try.

3. The custom hydroponics tray, with the input drilled lower than the output (in the widths of the tray), would cause a messy water current within the tray when water is channeled through. This would cause waste products from the aquaponics water to retain in the tray for long periods of time rather than flowing to the filter zone, hence would hinder the process of cleaning the tray, which was supposed to be rather easy. He suggested adding walls to the inner parts of the tray, which can help facilitate a constant directional water flow instead of a messy one.

He also discussed with me about extensions and he inspired me to come out with one new idea that could expand the use of our project:

Mini-turbines could be placed at the water output on the attachment of the fish tank, which would be naturally powered by kinetic energy from the continuous flow of water, thus this would create electricity which can have other functions in the aquaponics system. Frankie suggested for me to go along with this as it is easy to accomplish and a fresh new idea which is useful, thus can help boost our project overall.

The new prototype sketch after returning from the factory looks like this:

Table


Tray


Today's discussion with Frankie was fulfilling, however, Frankie had doubts on the overall "table" design. He felt that there were much cheaper and better alternatives to this. This probably means that we have to risk our creativity using the current prototype or come out with a totally fresh design in the short amount of time given. At least, I now know what opinions a member of the public would have about our prototype. I do hope that we, as a group, can be inspired either to improve heavily on this design or somehow come out with a new design.

Credits:
Thanks to Frankie for all the advice!

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Entry 11: Meeting with Mentor (7)

7 June 2012

Today, we checked on our temporary set up and washed the fish tank. While doing this, my mentor realised that the leca tray we were using seemed to be quite dirty as well as that plant growth was unstable, hence with his help, we came up with the idea of integrating the "IKEA Hydroponics Kit" into the project, acting as a replacement for the present leca tray. 

Here is a picture of the Hydroponics kit:


The advantages of using the new tray are that it is much easier to handle as compared to monitoring the leca kit, as well as allows for better plant growth as there is no presence of overcrowding, which boosts plant growth. However, there are only 6 pits which hold the plants (and very few leca), thus there is a limitation to the amount of the plants that can be grown.

Of course, we did sketches of the new tray and are going to modify it by drilling 2 holes, 1 in the front and 1 in the back to allow water to be transported into and out of the tray via tubes. Therefore, the latest prototype design we have right now is the same as that from the previous post, except with the tray changed to the modified hydroponics kit.



Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Entry 10: Meeting with Mentor (6)

5 June 2012

Today is the first meeting with our mentor in the holidays. The sketches of the display stand of the prototype has been completed. 

Prototype Design:


The prototype's most prominent structure is the display table placed over the fish tank. The table is extendable via a sliding mechanism in the middle, which is made to fit any length of a home-sized fish tank. The legs of the display stand are extendable via lock keys which are then inserted into the holes in the legs when of the desired height (markings will be provided). There are holes on the table which are meant for hanging the terraces, which can contain a different type of plant than the tray on the display stand filled with leca. However, due to the tubing, the limitations of this is that only one terrace can be connected to tube coming from the tube. Thus, only one terrace can be used, while the holes on the edges of the other 3 sides can be used to hook items (in hook baskets) such as fish food. 

The tray on the display stand contains leca, which cultivates plant growth. A tube inlet and outlet are attached on the tray which allows a continuous cyclic flow of water throughout the system to ensure that the water from the fish tank is being transported into and away from the tray of leca (and plants).

So far, the only problem we find with the current design is possibly that this item is considered merely a table,  however, it is true that we will modify it specifically to suit the Indoor Herb Chinampas. Hence, we can consider the problem to be solved already.

We will continue to work on this prototype in the future.

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Entry 9: Meeting with group members

23 May 2012

Today, the entire group sat down to meet up once again. This meeting was for us to discuss on the progress on finding for the external help as well as for us to set down our work plans for the month of June, which is extremely crucial to the project.

Regarding the progress on finding and getting an external help, Keven and Gordon has been unable to get any help as they do not have any contacts in this area. While Ching Kai Xiang is currently speaking to Frankie, to see whether he is interested in helping us out.

As for the workplan during the June they are as follow:

Details
Due by
Action by
External help found
28/05/2012
All
Confirmation of Prototype
04/05/2012
All
Creation of website
10/06/2012
Keven Loo
Sourcing of materials
11/06/2012
All
Creation of prototype
15/06/2012
All


While here are the confirmed dates for meeting with our Mentor:

Date
Time
Action by
29 May 2012
1400 - 1500 / 1500 - 1600
Ching, Keven
5 June 2012
1400 -  1500 / 1500 - 1600
Ching, Keven
7 June 2012
1400 – 1500 / 1500 - 1600
All
12 June 2012
1400 – 1500 / 1500 - 1600
All

The reason as to why we aim to complete the core of our project during the June Holidays was because it would be when most of us are free and are thus able to commit ourselves to the project as compared to when school reopens where we will have other commitments such as our academics and CCAs.




Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Entry 8: Meeting with Mentor (5)

8 May 2012

Today, the entire group met up within the school library to have a group meeting where we mainly discussed the idea of the "table" aquaponics set up for our invention.

As mentioned previously, there are quite a bit of advantages with regards to a "table" aquaponics set up for our invention, such as this set up being able to provide optimum support for the leca tray, reducing the storage space and allow for more customisation to the set up as compared to previous designs. However, the entire group had uncertainties as this new design could just simply be a table, with the set ups placed above and below it.

Thus we discussed about further modifications could be made, to further improve this design as well as to make it not just a table put together with that of the aquaponics system. After much discussion, we have decided that for this design, instead of just putting the tray of leca at the top and the fish tank at the bottom with the tubing for the system running all over the place, we will drill holes into the top of the table to allow the tubing to pass through, such that it seems neat and presentable. Furthermore, this also empties up the rest of the table space for things to be placed on. This thus brings another additional plus point to this design where it allows for items to be stored on it. This itself is already a modification made to the table, which value adds our prototype.

At this time, we already had a table in mind that we could use and the next step was to start searching for external help who is able to advice us further as to whether this idea was feasible.




Thursday, April 26, 2012

Entry 7: Meeting with Mentor (4)

26 April 2012

Today, we had a project meeting with our mentor, where we sat down and discussed about the first prototype design that we had.

We discussed about how the stand was to be made as the remaining components for that prototype could be bought and installed easily. However, in the end we scrapped this idea as well.

This is because of the fact that the stand that was to be created would not be strong enough to support the tray of leca. Furthermore, it is extremely costly to custom make the stands such that it is thin enough to clasp onto the fish tank and strong enough to hold on to the leca tray at the same time. Next, it only allows for minimal customisation, whereby we can only change the colour of the tray, and stand. We are unable to customise the size of the prototype where the size is fixed to that of the fish tank.

Since we have decided to scrap the above ideas, we then have to come up with new ideas that would work since we already have had experience with the previous prototypes. Through this session, we brainstormed on a few ideas, but ultimately, we decided on one idea that seemed feasible and practical. It was the idea of a table aquaponics set up. It was basically an idea of installing the aquaponics system onto a table where the fish tank would be underneath the table and the leca tray above the table.

This solves the problem of support for the leca tray, reduces storage space required for the aquaponics set up, as well as allows for a lot of customisation for the table, tray and even the fish tank. This allows our aquaponics prototype to integrate into households easily.

After the meeting today, we will be having another project group meeting among the group members to discuss further on the potential of this design.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Entry 6: Meeting with Mentor (3)

4 April 2012

Today, we had another meeting with our mentor after we passed the preliminary round of the Projects Competition.

In this meeting, we discussed about how our project will progress thereafter and also the feasibility in building of the prototypes that we have designed previously. Regarding the direction of our project, we basically set a timeline up for ourselves as to when each stage of our project must be completed by.

Here is our timeline:
April (Finalising of prototype design, materials that are to be used)
May (Contacting of external help, preparation of materials) 
June (Building of prototype)
July (Semi-Finals)

Regarding the building of the prototypes that we have designed previously, our group has decided to scrap the prototype design with the "terraces" formation. Here's a picture of that design:
The reason why we chose to scrap this design was due to a few reasons. Firstly, the design was not feasible. Besides just the lica sliding along, the hook might not be able to support the weight of the lica at all resulting in the entire prototype to fail. Secondly, the time taken for the water to travel one cycle around the various terraces would take too long and also there is a chance that water will remain stagnant because water will only travel when the first terrace is full. This will also result in the lack of nutrients by the fish waste for subsequent terraces as they might already be used up by the plants in the first terrace. Furthermore, our project emphasises a lot on simplicity on the process of the creation of the prototype and this design is quite complicated. Last but not least, plastic is used for the creation of the terraces and it is hard to find the suitable type of plastic for the terraces.

After this meeting, project members have gone back home to check out the feasibility and practicality of the other prototype design.