Thursday, April 26, 2012

Entry 7: Meeting with Mentor (4)

26 April 2012

Today, we had a project meeting with our mentor, where we sat down and discussed about the first prototype design that we had.

We discussed about how the stand was to be made as the remaining components for that prototype could be bought and installed easily. However, in the end we scrapped this idea as well.

This is because of the fact that the stand that was to be created would not be strong enough to support the tray of leca. Furthermore, it is extremely costly to custom make the stands such that it is thin enough to clasp onto the fish tank and strong enough to hold on to the leca tray at the same time. Next, it only allows for minimal customisation, whereby we can only change the colour of the tray, and stand. We are unable to customise the size of the prototype where the size is fixed to that of the fish tank.

Since we have decided to scrap the above ideas, we then have to come up with new ideas that would work since we already have had experience with the previous prototypes. Through this session, we brainstormed on a few ideas, but ultimately, we decided on one idea that seemed feasible and practical. It was the idea of a table aquaponics set up. It was basically an idea of installing the aquaponics system onto a table where the fish tank would be underneath the table and the leca tray above the table.

This solves the problem of support for the leca tray, reduces storage space required for the aquaponics set up, as well as allows for a lot of customisation for the table, tray and even the fish tank. This allows our aquaponics prototype to integrate into households easily.

After the meeting today, we will be having another project group meeting among the group members to discuss further on the potential of this design.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Entry 6: Meeting with Mentor (3)

4 April 2012

Today, we had another meeting with our mentor after we passed the preliminary round of the Projects Competition.

In this meeting, we discussed about how our project will progress thereafter and also the feasibility in building of the prototypes that we have designed previously. Regarding the direction of our project, we basically set a timeline up for ourselves as to when each stage of our project must be completed by.

Here is our timeline:
April (Finalising of prototype design, materials that are to be used)
May (Contacting of external help, preparation of materials) 
June (Building of prototype)
July (Semi-Finals)

Regarding the building of the prototypes that we have designed previously, our group has decided to scrap the prototype design with the "terraces" formation. Here's a picture of that design:
The reason why we chose to scrap this design was due to a few reasons. Firstly, the design was not feasible. Besides just the lica sliding along, the hook might not be able to support the weight of the lica at all resulting in the entire prototype to fail. Secondly, the time taken for the water to travel one cycle around the various terraces would take too long and also there is a chance that water will remain stagnant because water will only travel when the first terrace is full. This will also result in the lack of nutrients by the fish waste for subsequent terraces as they might already be used up by the plants in the first terrace. Furthermore, our project emphasises a lot on simplicity on the process of the creation of the prototype and this design is quite complicated. Last but not least, plastic is used for the creation of the terraces and it is hard to find the suitable type of plastic for the terraces.

After this meeting, project members have gone back home to check out the feasibility and practicality of the other prototype design.

Monday, March 19, 2012

Entry 5: Meeting with Mentor (2)


19 March 2012

Today we had a meeting with our mentor to discuss about the prototypes we have used and their effectiveness. We managed to choose the prototype ideas to work on and finalise these prototype designs with our mentor’s suggestions.

The first prototype that we chose:



Basically, the most significant design feature in the prototype would be the tray. The tray would be rectangular in shape and this allows water to flow around it equally, ensuring effective and fair plant growth. The tray is filled with leca, which are small and ball-like and unlike soil, it does not contain small harmful particles that may poison the fish tank and harm the fish. There are holes in-built into the tray which contains filter such that the filtered, clean water can re-enter the tray via gravity. The tray is supported by stilts, which are attached from the top of the fish tank to the tray and support the tray directly above the fish tank. The water is first pumped into the tray, then after flowing to the end of the tray, the water is filtered before re-entering the tank.

The second prototype that we chose:




This prototype utilizes trays placed on the exterior of the fish tank to transport water throughout the system. The trays wrap around the sides of the fish tank, which helps boost aesthetics and support. The trays are supported by hooks which cling on to the top of the fish tank, though we are still researching more efficient methods for attachment. There is also an in-built filter incorporated r to filter water before it re-enters the tank. Also, the trays, like the first prototype design, are filled with leca and in each of these trays, different types of plants/herbs can be grown. We have come up with 2 designs for the base of the tray:

First, we have the gently sloping design. This design allows water to flow down the trays quickly with the help of gravity, which saves time and energy. Furthermore, with a gentle slope, leca will not be transported with the water to one side of the tray and retain their positions.

Second, we have the “rice terrace” design.  This base design contains steps of different elevations. This allows water to flow down the trays with energy exerted from the pump as well as gravity, which also saves time. However, this type of base can retain leca more securely, with leca being retained on each step of the base due it not being directly sloped diagonally.

Water is first pumped into the tray at the highest point of the tank, in which water will flow down each of the trays and finally, upon reaching the end of the last tray, water is filtered then pumped back into the tank and as long as the pumps are switched on, the cycle is continuous.

Thus, these 2 prototype designs were our finalised prototype ideas that we would work on and modify in the future.

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Entry 4: Meeting at IKEA


13 March 2012

Today, we went to IKEA see some of the innovative and perhaps eco-friendly systems that they have been known for, which would then, hopefully, provide for us some ideas to work on in our project.
Even though the first prototype idea had already been formulated, we decided that it would be best that we come up with more ideas first so that we can compare and perhaps modify these prototypes before receiving a prototype that would receive the best of all worlds. Thus, out main purpose in going to IKEA was to develop new ideas and methods to create the Indoor Aquaponics System which had to boast eco-friendliness, convenience and pleasant aesthetics.

The IKEA that we went to was quite small, and thus, the selection of items in it was limited. Because of this, we were unable to find many outstanding or special products which we were ideally looking for. However, when we sat down to rest for a bit, we realised the truth was, the products we needed were actually all around us.

The first idea that we formulated was an idea to create a flowing tray aquaponics system. The trays containing plants and leca in which water would be pumped into were to be placed on the exterior of the fish tank, which was attached to the sides of the fish tank.  Although this idea seemed viable and unique, there were many problems that we anticipated. First, we had no idea how the trays were going to be attached to the tank. Thus, this already affected the effectiveness of our prototype. Furthermore, we also realised that placing the tray at the front of the tank would definitely hinder convenience and aesthetics of the setup. However, we managed to develop ideas for the base of the tray, which were the slope plane as well as the “rice terrace” idea. The slope plane allowed for water to flow down efficiently, however leca would also flow down with the water, which was undesirable. The “rice terrace” base would allow leca to be retained, but the flow of water could be affected.

The second idea that we formulated was to make a hole in the centre of the fish tank, then grow plants in the centre of the fish tank. This boosted the aesthetics of the fish tank, as well as allowed for the effective growth of plants due to it being directly exposed to the light source for the fish tank. However, this idea lacked the factor of convenience to remove it, and we could not think of a suitable container to fill in the hole of the fish tank. The plants that could be grown were also limited due to the lack of space when the hole had four sides which obstructed plant growth. Finally, we realised that we were not being eco-friendly in this idea. Despite the fact that this idea had many flaws, we may still consider improving and using this prototype in the future.

Thus, with all these ideas we had obtained, we concluded that we would finalise these ideas with our mentor in the next meeting.

Thursday, February 23, 2012

Entry 3: Meeting with Mentor (1)


23 February 2012

Today we had a meeting with our mentor discussing about our previously mentioned ideas. We decided to work on the integrating the external large setups into our houses.

This is because of the feasibility of the two ideas. The idea of revamping the large outdoor setup was just not too feasible due to the lack of technical expertise and that it will not be able to aid anyone, because it would require for someone to own a moderate size piece of land just for that system to operate. As compared to that of the indoor aquaponics, it will definitely be much more feasible as we need to come up with the designs, and the technical part of it is pretty simple, and yet able to benefit much more people as it will be integrated into their households and this idea of an indoor aquaponics helps to prevent dengue too as the water is in constant motion.

After this meeting, we needed to think of various ideas and designs regarding the indoor aquaponics as well as how this will work. Along with the benefits of each idea and design as well as how aesthetically pleasing it is, we will then decide on which design to work on, which will therefore be our prototypes. This will actually be based on our basic idea, which we have actually done up some time ago for a green fair.

Here is a picture of our basic idea:




During this session, we came up with the idea for one of the possible prototypes. It was actually somewhat similar to this idea, except much more aesthetically pleasing and uses much lesser space, whereby the tray will be attached to the fish tank directly, with our own invented support holder for the tank to the tray. This will actually maybe become one of our eventual decided prototype.

Here is a picture of how the prototype could actually look like:


Beyond this idea, we would need to continue doing our work and think of various other designs and ideas before selecting the best during our project meeting with our mentor.

Friday, February 17, 2012

Entry 2: Invention Ideas

17 February 2012

Since we were already presented with a faulty setup in the large aquaponics setup within the school, close to the science lab, we were allowed to come up with our own idea as to what we actually wanted to do. We camp up with two ideas.

Our first idea was to actually come up with a brand new outdoor aquaponics system, by changing around the various parts of the faulty system, such as replacing the position of the fish tank (nutrients provider), making adjustments to the position of pipes, drainage of water as well as how water is distributed to the plants.

Our second idea was to integrate this external large aquaponics setup that could only be setup in plots of land with huge spaces into our modern houses, allowing it to integrate both fish tanks as well as mini plant gardens. Whereby this fish tanks will then become the nutrient provider to the plant garden.

Issues faced regarding the first idea include:
How were we going to be able to cut the plastic parts needed?
Since we did not know much about how to work around with the plumbing would it actually be even possible for us to change the positions of the pipe and work around with the drainage system?
What were the benefits as well as the feasibility of this idea?

Issues faced regarding the second idea include:
How were we going to make it aesthetically pleasing?
How will this actually work out and its feasibility?

We then came to a conclusion of meeting up with our mentor for a discussion before deciding on which idea to work on.

Friday, February 3, 2012

Entry 1: Category to Enter

3rd February 2012

A few weeks ago, our group had decided to do a project on aquaponics due to the exposure we had on it in Secondary 2 and the fact that it had potential in several project categories. However, due to the broad diversity of ideas we formulated with aquaponics, we had not chosen a specific category to enter our project in yet.

The first project category that the group was contemplating to join was the Service Learning Project. In the previous meeting, we had decided that we could introduce and integrate aquaponics to large scale farming industries nowadays and work towards more environmentally friendly methods of carrying out industrial activities. At the same time, we could, with our set up, also produce organic vegetables to be donated to the poor, thus reaching out to the less fortunate in our community. The purposes that we had in the project fulfilled the criteria of Service Learning, thus it was one of the most viable options we had. However, there were several problems that we only realised today. First, there are limited farming areas in Singapore. Thus, if we wanted the project to be large scale, we had to focus on promoting the system overseas, which could be troublesome and difficult to accomplish due to the short timeframe we had. Next, the already short timeframe also amounted to a low amount of food supplies that we could produce; As each vegetable took about 2-3 months to grow, with our limited number of set ups, we would not be able to produce enough food to serve the community. In fact, our contributions in this sector would more or less become negligible. Another lingering problem was that one of the aquaponics set-ups we had was faulty and water was unable to flow through the system smoothly, thus leading to the inability to use it. Thus, we had no choice but to look towards an alternative project.

Even though we shunned the idea of inventing a new prototype at first, the fact that there was a faulty aquaponics system gave us an idea – if we were able to come up with a successful prototype that would not only be able to replace the faulty system but also achieve other uses, then it would fufill the criteria for the Inventions Category! During the meeting, we decided to create a hydroponics system that would not only help to promote environmental friendliness The recent interests that people have expressed in aquaponics systems also spurred us to go deeper and explore further. Through all these ideas, we finally decided:

We were going to embark on an aquaponics project in the Inventions Category!